The Table · Sermons
Sermons
The Table Church
Sermons
Practicing Resurrection
Sunday, April 16, 2023

Recovering from Spiritual Trauma

Content note. This sermon discusses spiritual abuse and religious trauma.
Listen · 28 min
When God feels far away
0:00−27:51
Podbean ↗

Sunday, April 16, 2023. Preacher: Anthony Parrott.

The good news: we can heal from trauma!

The bad news: abuse and trauma can make the things that can bring healing seem bad.

It is a clinically proven fact that the one thing that can help someone heal from abuse, neglect, or trauma is relationship.

In foster and adoptive world, where I come from, children that suffer neglect or abuse begin to fear all forms of relationship.

So we end up in paradox. We want to feel close to God. Community, small groups, prayer, Bible study worship, meditation can help. But now they taste like food-poisioning chorizo.

More detail

Chapters8 sections
TranscriptAuto-generated · 4,209 words

Generated automatically from the audio, so names and some words may be wrong. Tap any sentence to hear it.

When God feels far away

We've had this observation show up in our community recently, and we've talked about it a couple times, and that's what this sermon series is going to be about, that for a lot of us, we've spent significant amounts of time working on our theology, working on our beliefs about God and Christianity and faith and justice, and that's kind of become settled for us. We now believe in things that are no longer toxic or hateful or no longer causing us to have vitriol against others or to cast out entire sections of society. We have a theology that seems like a more beautiful gospel, and God seems really far away.

The way that we've said it is that our relationship with God sucks. God seems more distant than ever. For some of us, and again, this is going to be towards, like, sort of a particular set of people who have gone down that deconstruction and reconstruction path with their faith.

Maybe they found faith as a child, and they've had to unlearn and relearn some things. Maybe you found faith as an adult, and then you hit some, like, really harsh realities about the immaturities of that faith, and you've had to start over again. But regardless, this is towards that sort of crowd of people, or you've reworked your faith, but now all the things that you remember used to kind of set you on fire for Jesus, then now they seem corny, or dangerous, maybe even triggering.

Things like church services, and worship songs, and even prayer. And I think for a lot of folks who find themselves in this boat, you want to feel God's presence again. You want to feel spiritual, whatever that means.

But it just seems like there's a barrier. You're stuck. You can't.

Something that used to be alive inside of you is now dead. Now, the good news about this is that you're not alone. One of the most hopeful phrases in the English vocabulary is me too.

And I have heard these sorts of stories, not just from, like, the one person I'm preaching at today, but from a variety of y'all. Of you've worked on your theology, you've worked on your beliefs, but God still seems so distant. And you're not alone, because Scripture talks about this very thing.

Psalm 42’s argument with itself

There's this psalm, Psalm chapter 42, I said I'm going to quote a bunch of poetry at you today. Psalm 42 has this songwriter having an argument with herself. One part of her keeps asking, why are you depressed?

You shouldn't be depressed. And the other part of her responds, but you are, deal with it. So listen to Psalm 42.

Just like a deer that craves streams of water, my whole being craves you, God. My whole being thirsts for God, for the living God. When will I come and see God's face?

My tears have been my food both day and night as people constantly question me, where's your God now? But I remember these things as I bare my soul, how I made my way to the Mighty One's abode, to God's own house. I used to do it with joyous shouts and Thanksgiving songs, a huge crowd celebrating the festival.

So I ask myself, why are you so depressed? Why are you so upset inside, just hope in God? because I'll give him thanks again my saving presence of my God.

And then the other side of the author responds, but my whole being is depressed. That's why I try to remember you, God, from all the lands of my people. Deep has called out to deep at the sound of your waterfalls.

All the waves have surged over me. By day, the Lord commands his faithful love. By night, his song was with me.

The prayer to God of my life, I will say to my God, my solid rock, why have you forgotten me? Why do I have to walk around sad and oppressed? With my bones crushed, my foes make fun of me.

So I ask myself, why are you so depressed? Why are you so upset inside? Just hope in God, because I will give him again thanks, my saving presence and my God.

And so you hear this argument, this back and forth. I used to be really into it. I used to wish heaven was an eternal Hillsong concert.

But now that just doesn't seem to do the trick anymore. I used to want to go to the house of God and experience the joy and the thanksgiving. And now I'm just sad and depressed and downcast and I don't even know why.

David, the author of Psalm 51, begs God like this. Create a clean heart for me, God. Put a new faithful spirit deep inside of me.

Please don't throw me out from your presence. Please don't take your Holy Spirit away from me. Return the joy of your salvation to me and sustain me with a willing spirit.

And I feel like that prayer is sort of the rallying cry of these next six or seven weeks of sermons. Return unto me, as the song says, the joy of my salvation. For many of us, for a lot of us, there was this simple joy in knowing Jesus and knowing God and reading your Bible and singing the worship songs and going to church and praying and being part of a small group.

And for many, many of us, that joy is subsided now into either cynicism or despair or just sort of a going through the motions. Your theology is solid. It's great. But God seems distant.

Eastertide and Wendell Berry’s poem

So we're calling in this series Practicing Resurrection. Lent is a 40-day season that leads up to Easter. And then Easter doesn't just end on Easter Day.

It's actually the kickoff to a 50-day season called Eastertide up till Pentecost. And so there's the folks who designed the church calendar centuries ago. They did that on purpose.

that the fasting would last not as long as the feasting that happens in Eastertide. And so these 50 days are meant to be an occasion of celebration and joy that Christ has risen, he has risen indeed, that the resurrection is the big bang of new creation. And so in this series, we want to look at our own lives with God and hopefully see some resurrection in there as well.

So the phrase, Practice Resurrection, comes from a poem, I told you, more poetry, by American novelist, poet, climate activist, and farmer, Wendell Berry. And the poem goes like this. Love, this is written in the 70s, by the way.

Love the quick profit, the annual raise, vacation with pay. Want more of everything ready-made. Be afraid to know your neighbors.

and to die. And you will have a window into your head. Not even your future will be a mystery anymore. Your mind will be punched in a card and shut away in a little drawer. When they want you to buy something, they will call you. When they want you to die for profit, they will let you know. So, friends, every day do something that won't compute. Love the Lord. Love the world. Work for nothing. Take all that you have and be poor. Love someone who does not deserve it. Denounce the

government and embrace the flag. Hope to live in that free republic for which it stands. Give your approval to all you cannot understand. Praise ignorance for what man has not encountered he has not destroyed. Ask the questions that have no answers. Invest in the millennium. Plant sequoias. Say that your main crop is the forest that you did not plant, that you will not live to harvest. Say that the leaves are harvested when they have rotted into the mold. Call that

profit. Prophesy such returns. Put your faith in the two inches of humus that will build under the trees every thousand years. Listen to carrion. Put your ear close and hear the faint chattering of the songs that are to come. Expect the end of the world.

Laugh. Laughter is immeasurable. Be joyful though you have considered all the facts.

So long as women do not go cheap for power, please women more than men. Somebody just asked me a little bit ago about why there's so few men at the Table Church. It's because we read poems like these.

So long as women do not go cheap for power, please women more than men. Ask yourself, Will this satisfy a woman satisfied to bear a child? Will this disturb the sleep of a woman near to giving birth?

Go with your love to the fields. Lie easy in the shade. Rest your head in her lap and swear allegiance to what is nighest to your thoughts.

And as soon as the generals and the politicos can predict the motions of your mind, lose it. Leave it as a sign to mark the false trail the way you didn't go. Be like the fox who makes more tracks than necessary.

some in the wrong direction, practice resurrection.

Resurrection is earthy and physical

Now, Pastor Tonetta, she used to be a high school English teacher, and so she would be the better one to lead us in a critical analysis of this poem. But I'll do my best. Notice that for Wendell Berry, practicing resurrection is not this super spiritual act.

Instead, it's earthy, and it's tangible, and it's physical. And the Bible speaks of resurrection and life with God in the same way. Like, if you listen to Jesus' parables, they all have this sort of earthy, physical, tangible quality to them.

The kingdom of heaven is like a mustard seed that's sown and planted into a field, and it grows up into the largest plant, and then the birds of the air find their nest in it. The kingdom of heaven is like yeast that a woman works into dough and then it finds its way into all of the dough. The kingdom of heaven is like a treasure hidden in a field worth selling everything you have and purchasing.

The kingdom of heaven is like a net let down to catch fish. It's like a wedding banquet where everyone is invited, even those who live on the wrong side of the tracks. The kingdom is like a farmer sowing seed, spreading it wherever it will go.

The kingdom, according to Jesus, is not fluffy clouds. It's not harps and pearly gates. Rather, Jesus' parables and Jesus' explanation of the kingdom of heaven is about the stuff you can touch and taste and smell and see.

It's like dirt under the fingernails. It's not super spiritual acts of mysticism. It's banquets and seeds.

I mean, just look at the way that Jesus spends his time after his resurrection. I pointed out last week that Jesus is resurrected. He spends most of his first day in a new body with a bunch of sad people.

He doesn't go to Caesar. He doesn't go to Pilate. He doesn't go to his enemies and try to get vindication. Rather, he goes to his sad, grieving disciples and spends the day with them.

And he keeps eating. Luke 24, chapter, yeah, verse 30. Jesus meets with the disciples on the road to Emmaus.

He walks them to their house, and it's when Jesus breaks bread that the disciples are like, oh, I know who you are now. You're the guy who's always like eating stuff. Eleven verses later, Jesus appears to the disciples who are in a locked room. They think they're seeing a ghost, and Jesus is like, ah, no, can I have some more food, please?

John chapter 21, Jesus shows up on the beach. The disciples are fishing in a boat. They see the smoke rising from the beach. Peter jumps out of the boat, swims to the shore, and there's Jesus cooking some fish for the disciples to share a meal with him.

Jesus' resurrection life, again, is not clouds and harps and the eternal worship concert. It is stuff here on earth. And so I think if we are to practice resurrection in our own lives, in our own quote-unquote spiritual life, we have to talk about our bodies, about things that are tangible and earthy and have to do with food and drink and fellowship and this thing we call reality.

And that's not to say that so-called spiritual things don't matter. Singing and prayer and meditation and preaching and visions and prophecy and spiritual gifts, all of that matters too. But it matters because of their physicality, not in spite of it.

Spirituality is at its best when it is very physical. Singing is powerful because it engages our lungs and our voices. And when you hear a drum, it gets all of our hearts beating in the same rhythm.

Prayer and meditation are powerful because it slows down our breathing and our heart rate and it stills our bodies. Spending time together in a space like this or in a home or around a table is a spiritual act, but it's powerful because it's a physical act that gets us together. And we start sharing the stories of our lives and eventually sharing the scars of our lives.

So if we are to practice resurrection, if we are to experience the joy of our salvation once again, this only can't be a sermon series about a bunch of like, quote-unquote, spiritual practices only, though I love spiritual practices. It's about what we do with our bodies.

Defining trauma and spiritual abuse

Now, in order to sort of, like, plow the path for the preachers that are going to come after me for the next few weeks, if we're going to talk about our spiritual lives, if we're going to talk about practicing resurrection, if we're going to talk about our theology being great but our relationship with God sucking, then we have to talk about trauma and spiritual abuse, okay? So, bit of a content warning, if you don't want to hear about trauma and spiritual abuse, you're welcome to go to the bathroom, find a snack, find a drink, take a walk, and come back when you're ready for communion, that's okay. So, trauma, to give you a quick definition, is an event or an experience that overwhelms a person's capacity to cope.

Trauma is an event or an experience or a series of events or experiences that overwhelms a person's capacity to cope. So if you go into the world with sort of the normal tool bag of tools that everyone has to get along with people and society and feelings and emotions and social interactions, and then you encounter an event or a series of events that overwhelms that normal set of tools, that is a traumatic experience, okay?

And it's important to remember that what may be trauma for you may not be trauma for someone else and vice versa. So you can't just say this by itself is a traumatic experience and that's true for everyone. Everyone has a different sort of threshold of what could be traumatic for them depending on their background, the tools that were given to them in their childhood, things like that.

So that's trauma, and there are a variety of different kinds of trauma. Physical trauma is pretty easy to understand. If you are in a car accident, if you are in an injury, it overwhelms your physical body's capacity to cope with the normal interactions of gravity and physics.

And something breaks, something gets bruised. And so that's physical trauma, but there's also emotional trauma and social trauma, and there are spiritual trauma. Now, to talk about spiritual trauma, we've got to talk about spiritual abuse.

I want to give you a definition. Spiritual abuse is a form of emotional and psychological abuse, and it's characterized by a systematic pattern of coercive and controlling behavior in a religious context. Spiritual abuse can have a deeply damaging impact on those who experience it.

This abuse may include manipulation, exploitation, enforced accountability, censorship of decision-making, requirements of secrecy and silence, coercion to conform, an inability to ask questions, control through the use of sacred texts or teaching, the requirement of obedience to the abuser, the suggestion that the abuser has a divine position, isolation as a means of punishment, and superiority and elitism.

And this comes from a book called Escaping the Maze of Spiritual Abuse. And it's kind of become a standard definition for this sort of thing. Now, if you have spent any time in religious environments like churches, there can be a tendency to migrate towards any one of those items on that list.

And sometimes, maybe even oftentimes, it starts out as a good intent. Pastors, people like me, spiritual leaders, we want people to grow. We want people to experience Jesus.

We want people to have a great spiritual life. And so any organization requires some amount of commitment-making, boundary-setting, rule-making. And if you try to have an organization without any of that, things fall apart pretty quickly.

But because humans are humans, and because people tend to seek power, those good intentions can very easily get twisted into abuse. And it becomes abuse when there is an asymmetry in power between a person with some kind of spiritual authority and somebody else. It's most noticeable when it's not just a single case, but it's a continual pattern.

And it can penetrate an entire church culture that it becomes systemic. And then it's psychological, and it's emotional, and it's spiritually wounding. So that's trauma and abuse.

When good things feel poisoned

Now, why bring this up right now? Well, the thing about trauma is that it can ruin what's good. As a silly example, I used to really love chorizo, like the Mexican sausage, and it's a spicy sausage.

I used to really love it. It's great in breakfast food. It's great in tacos and burritos. It's a really, really good food. I used to really love chorizo until I got food poisoning. And up came the chorizo.

Another content warning, sorry. And then it became really difficult to even, like, look at chorizo ever again. Okay?

Trauma and abuse is a form of poisoning against even things that can by themselves be good. And so the things that used to move you, worship music and prayer and church services and small groups and Bible studies, all of those things that maybe used to move you closer to God, give you a sense of connection with the divine, you put that in an abusive or traumatic environment long enough, and then it becomes like poison chorizo.

The things that used to move you closer to God have now been poisoned, and now you try to come back to them. and it's just not the same. And I think that happens to a lot of the folks that show up here at the Table.

You come to a Sunday environment like this, you go to a small group, you hear the worship songs, you do a Bible study, and you go into it. Some of you have gone into it with great intent. You're ready to connect with God again.

Maybe you've come back to the church after you've experienced any form of discrimination, any form of hatred, you come back to church, you're ready to connect with God, and then it's just not the same, and it's not just like a wax, the power that it used to, but it's like making you sick inside. And some of you have explained to me like this tension that you feel within yourself of you want to get close to God again, you want to engage in these spiritual practices again,

but every time you try, it feels poisoned, it feels awful. Now, the good news about trauma is that you can heal from it. If you have a traumatic experience in your life, if you had these adverse things that have happened in your past, you can heal from trauma, okay?

The harder thing about it, though, is abuse and trauma can make the things that work towards your healing seem bad to you. And so it creates this paradox where the things that you need to heal from spiritual trauma and abuse, they make you sick. But it's a clinically proven fact that the one thing that can help someone heal from abuse, neglect, or trauma is relationship.

But in the foster and adoptive world, which is, I was a foster kid, I come out of that world, and I've studied a lot of stuff within that world. Children that suffer neglect or abuse begin to fear all forms of relationship. And so the very thing that they need is the very thing that they're afraid of.

Because that good thing was used to hurt them. So the same thing can happen in a spiritual life. Where the very thing that you need to connect with God, those earthy, tangible practices, well, they were used to harm you.

And so our bodies have this defense mechanism, which is good. It's protecting you. It's a tool, but it's preventing you from healing.

So we end up in this paradox where we want to feel close to God, but community and small groups and prayer and Bible study and worship and music and meditation, they now taste like food-poison chorizo. And so what this series is wanting to do is offer some tools to unpoison the well.

God is good, and not against you

Now to do that, to sort of end tonight, I just want to begin with a reminder that God is good. Which, you know, sounds really simple and obvious. But I think one of the most basic lies that we can be told and that we can believe and that can sink down deep inside of us is that God is good, but it's not the goodness that you expect.

God is good, but good, and you can't trust your own understanding about what good is. God's ways are far above our ways. Our righteousness is like filthy rags.

God is good, but you don't know what it is, so you just have to trust that whatever we say God is good means, that's what it means, and don't trust yourself. And that's where we'll talk a little bit about trusting yourself again next week. But when we say something like God is good, I believe the language has to mean something in order for it to be useful.

And so Jesus tells us, Matthew chapter 7, Ask and you will receive. Search and you will find. Knock and the door will be opened to you.

For everyone who asks, receives. Whoever seeks, finds. And to everyone who knocks, the door is opened.

Who among you would give your child a stone when they ask for bread or give them a snake when they ask for fish? If you, who are evil, Jesus kind of throwing down there, if you, who are evil, know how to give good gifts to children, how much more will your heavenly parents give good things to those who ask? In other words, when we say God is good, it's not like a trick.

It's not like a theological gotcha. If you know what goodness is, how much more good is God's goodness? And so, you know, I encourage a lot of folks in our church who are experiencing spiritual trauma and abuse who have in their life to, you know, practice some basic, like, meditation, centering, prayer sort of tools.

And they hit this barrier right away because there's a fear about going to God. that God's basic posture towards us is one of anger and vengeance. And so one of the first things that somebody has to deconstruct is that God is against you and that God's basic posture towards you is anger and hatred.

If we know how to give good gifts to children, how much more does God know how to give good things to those who ask? So I want to conclude tonight's sermon with a simple meditation going back to the words of Psalm 52.

Praying Psalm 51 together

And we're just going to slowly say these words out loud together. And this comes from Eugene Peterson's Message translation of the Psalms. And we're just going to say these as a prayer with some deep breaths in between each line.

And make this sort of the basic ask and seek and knock of our next six or seven weeks together. So, let's say a line out loud together, do a deep inhale and exhale, and then say the next line. All together, God, make a fresh start in me.

Take a deep breath. The next two lines, shape a Genesis week from the chaos of my life. Together, you won't throw me out with the trash.

Or fail to breathe holiness in me. Together, bring me back from the gray exile. Last line, put a fresh wind in my sails.

Keep listening